CEA CRASH COURSE
IN EMPLOYEE BENEFITS
MODULE 04 / 06   ·   2026 EDITION

Tax-Advantaged
Accounts

Understand how FSAs, HRAs, and HSAs fund care—and how their tax, eligibility, and ownership rules differ.

Watch, read, or use both.

YOUR COURSE MATERIALS

Keep the slides handy.

The slide download will be available here.

↓   Download the slides
Jump to a section

Three similar names. Three very different promises.

An FSA, an HRA, and an HSA can all help pay medical expenses with favorable tax treatment. But they differ in who supplies the money, when it becomes available, what happens to unused amounts, and who controls the benefit.

Those differences matter when you recommend a plan. An employer might want to help employees with a higher deductible while retaining money that is never needed for claims. Another employer might prefer to deposit money into accounts that employees own permanently. An employee might want a predictable way to pay for next year’s dental work, while a coworker wants to build savings for medical expenses years from now. These are different objectives, and the right account depends on the objective.

These accounts belong in the benefits conversation. They can help employees afford care, stretch compensation, or build future savings. Administration makes those promises work: elections must reach payroll, employees must understand the claim process, and reimbursements must follow the plan. Start with the benefit the employer wants to provide, then organize the administration around it.

This module has three main parts. First, we will examine Section 125 cafeteria plans, health flexible spending arrangements, and dependent care assistance. Next, we will look at health reimbursement arrangements and their different designs. Finally, we will work through health savings accounts, including the health coverage and personal eligibility requirements that determine who can contribute.

After this module, you should be able to:

  • Explain the difference between a premium-only plan, a health FSA, an HRA, and an HSA.
  • Describe the tax advantages without confusing a marginal tax rate with a tax rate on all income.
  • Distinguish an FSA’s annual election from its payroll deductions and an HRA allowance from an employee-owned balance.
  • Recognize the integration, eligibility, and coordination rules that affect account design.
  • Apply HSA contribution limits, family rules, and partial-year eligibility rules.
  • Identify the employer’s administrative responsibilities and the account holder’s recordkeeping responsibilities.

Current references reviewed October 15, 2026. Annual figures are labeled by year; the historical case study is an illustration, not a current quote.

Start with who funds it and who keeps it.

A cafeteria plan is the tax framework that lets eligible employees choose qualified benefits instead of taxable cash. A premium-only plan is one application of that framework. A health FSA is another. A dependent care FSA serves a different purpose, and its benefits are governed by separate rules. HSA salary reductions can also run through a properly written cafeteria plan, but an HSA does not become a health FSA just because payroll sends the money.

An HRA is an employer-funded promise to reimburse specified expenses. An HSA is an individual trust or custodial account. The word “account” can make these arrangements sound interchangeable. They are not interchangeable in operation.

The core differences
FeatureHealth FSAHRAHSA
Who funds it?Usually employee salary reductions; employer contributions are also possible.Employer only. No employee salary reductions.The eligible individual, employer, or another person, subject to one combined limit.
What becomes available?The elected annual health benefit during the coverage period, even before all payroll deductions occur.Reimbursements under the employer’s plan terms.Money actually deposited and available in the account.
Unused amountsGenerally forfeited, subject to an optional permitted carryover or grace period.May carry forward if the plan permits. No unrestricted cash-out.Remain the account holder’s money from year to year.
Leaving the employerCoverage and claim rights follow plan and continuation rules.Remaining reimbursement rights follow plan and continuation rules.The individual keeps the account.
Who verifies medical claims?The plan or administrator substantiates claims.The plan or administrator substantiates claims.The account holder maintains evidence supporting tax-free distributions.

Sources: IRS Publication 969 and Notice 2002-45. [1] [9]

Each structure can be useful. The question is not which acronym is best in the abstract. The question is which arrangement solves the employer’s funding problem and the employees’ needs while fitting the health coverage being offered.

Buying less insurance does not make the underlying expense disappear.

When a health-plan renewal exceeds the employer’s budget, the employer must decide how to respond. A common response is to raise deductibles or reduce upfront copay benefits. That can lower the premium relative to a richer option, but it also shifts more of the initial expense to the employee.

A tax-advantaged account can help manage that shift. The employer may use part of the premium savings to reimburse claims through an HRA or contribute to an HSA. Employees may use an FSA or HSA to pay eligible expenses with dollars that receive favorable tax treatment. The account helps finance the expense; it does not make the expense free.

Consumerism requires more than a larger deductible.

The idea behind consumer-directed health care is that people make more deliberate choices when they can see costs and have a financial reason to consider them. That might mean comparing the allowed price of an imaging service at different facilities, asking about a lower-cost medication, or choosing an appropriate site of care.

That reasoning has limits. A patient in an emergency cannot shop the way someone shops for a television. Price information may be incomplete, and lower utilization can reflect either better decisions or delayed necessary care. A useful strategy therefore combines plan design with information, access, and help. Moving costs to employees without providing those tools can simply make the benefit harder to use.

An elective procedure such as LASIK can offer an opportunity to compare prices in advance. Emergency care presents very different circumstances, so a strategy must account for both planned and unplanned needs. Brokers should connect the account to practical support: network information, cost estimates, prescription options, covered preventive services, and a clear explanation of how claims and reimbursements work.

Also, not every account is inherently a consumer-directed strategy. A general-purpose FSA can sit beside a traditional copay plan. Its election process encourages budgeting, but its forfeiture rule can encourage hurried spending near year-end. An HSA’s permanent ownership creates a different incentive: money left unspent remains available for the future.

THE BROKER’S JOB

Explain the insurance, the account, and the employee’s remaining responsibility together. A lower premium is only one part of the comparison.

A payroll deduction needs the right plan behind it.

Ordinarily, compensation is taxable even if an employee chooses to spend it on a benefit. The constructive receipt concept also looks at cash that the employee could have received. Section 125 provides a framework under which choosing a qualified benefit instead of available taxable cash does not, by itself, make the benefit taxable.

For example, an employee can elect to have part of compensation applied to eligible group health premiums through a premium-only plan. A health FSA election sets aside compensation for eligible medical reimbursements. A dependent care election directs compensation toward qualifying care that enables work. The employer must establish and operate the appropriate written plan; calling a deduction “pre-tax” in payroll is not enough. [2]

Write the rules before operating the benefit.

The document describes the benefits, eligibility, plan year, contribution limits, election procedures, and permitted election changes. It should match what payroll and the administrator actually do. A document allowing only premium payments should not be assumed to authorize a health FSA or HSA salary reductions that are absent from its terms.

Establish the plan before its effective date and make elections prospectively under the applicable rules. Discovering in April that deductions have been treated as pre-tax since January does not make a newly signed document retroactively fix the earlier operation. The employer needs to address the prior payroll treatment as well as adopt the correct plan going forward.

A cafeteria plan normally has a 12-month plan year. A short first year or a change in plan year requires a valid business purpose, not a device for avoiding annual limits or election restrictions. A short health FSA plan year can also reduce the permissible salary-reduction maximum. These details belong in implementation discussions with the administrator. [3]

An employer may sponsor a plan even when its owner cannot participate.

The distinction is between the business’s ability to offer benefits to eligible employees and a particular owner’s ability to receive those benefits through Section 125. Sole proprietors, partners, and more-than-2% S corporation shareholders generally cannot participate in a cafeteria plan. S corporation attribution rules can extend the restriction to certain employed family members.

Do not use “LLC” as a complete tax answer. An LLC’s tax classification matters. A member of an LLC taxed as a partnership is treated differently from an employee-owner of an entity taxed as a C corporation. C corporation employee-shareholders can generally participate, subject to the applicable eligibility and nondiscrimination rules.

Eligible participants generally are employees, with specific statutory rules for certain leased employees and full-time life insurance agents who are statutory employees. A spouse or child whose expenses can be reimbursed is not thereby an employee-participant in the employer’s cafeteria plan. Similarly, a carrier’s willingness to insure a domestic partner does not automatically establish tax-free treatment. The relationship must meet the applicable tax rules. [2]

Related employers may also need to be considered together. Common control and affiliated service rules are more detailed than an informal “same owner” test. Coordinate the ownership analysis with the employer’s tax adviser instead of relying on one universal ownership percentage.

Choose an annual amount for expenses you can reasonably anticipate.

A health FSA allows an employee to elect an annual benefit for eligible medical, dental, and vision expenses. Payroll deductions then fund the employee’s elected salary reduction over the coverage period. It is particularly useful for expenses such as recurring prescriptions, expected dental treatment, or replacement eyeglasses.

For plan years beginning in 2026, the employee salary-reduction limit is $3,400. The employer may set a lower limit. This is not a self-only-versus-family limit: covering a spouse and children does not double the employee’s maximum. Spouses who are each eligible employees can each make their own permitted health FSA election, but the same expense cannot be reimbursed twice. [4]

2027 UPDATE

For plan years beginning in 2027, the IRS has raised the health FSA salary-reduction limit to $3,500, and the maximum carryover of unused 2027 amounts into the following plan year is $700. Use the 2026 amounts above ($3,400 and $680) for 2026 plan years. Health FSA limits are separate from the published 2027 HSA limits later in this lesson. [5]

The employer can contribute, too.

Employer money that employees cannot choose to take as cash generally does not count against the employee salary-reduction ceiling. A separate maximum-benefit test matters, however, when designing a health FSA as an excepted benefit. The maximum annual benefit cannot exceed the greater of twice the employee’s salary reduction or the employee’s salary reduction plus $500. Cashable employer credits can be treated as salary reductions for this purpose.

Illustrations of the health FSA excepted-benefit maximum
Employee salary reductionEmployer amount in the illustrationTotal benefit
$0$500$500
$250$500$750
$1,000$1,000$2,000

This test is also tied to the employer making other group health coverage, beyond excepted benefits, available to the relevant employees. The federal excepted-benefit rule does not itself require the employee to enroll in that medical coverage to use the FSA, although the employer’s plan can impose eligibility conditions. This offer requirement is not a requirement that every employee buy the employer’s medical plan. It also should not be applied indiscriminately to dependent care assistance. [6]

Calculate the tax savings on the dollars being redirected.

To estimate the savings from a $2,500 election, apply the marginal tax rates that would otherwise apply to those particular dollars. A 22% federal bracket does not mean every dollar of income is taxed at 22%, and a $50,000 gross salary by itself does not establish that bracket.

WORKED EXAMPLE

What happens to a $2,500 expense?

Assume the full $2,500 salary reduction would otherwise face a 22% marginal federal income tax rate and 7.65% employee Social Security and Medicare tax, with no state income tax included.

$2,500 × (22% + 7.65%) = $741.25 in estimated employee tax savings. The resulting reduction in take-home pay is $1,758.75, while $2,500 is available for eligible expenses under the FSA.

The employer’s matching FICA savings would be $2,500 × 7.65% = $191.25 under those assumptions. Compare aggregate savings with administration costs and the employer’s reimbursement exposure.

The 7.65% assumption combines 6.2% Social Security tax with 1.45% Medicare tax. Social Security has a wage ceiling: $184,500 in 2026 and $192,300 in 2027. Medicare’s basic tax has no wage ceiling, and additional Medicare tax can affect higher earners. Consequently, the same 7.65% marginal saving does not apply to every employee. State treatment also varies; Texas has no individual state income tax to add to this illustration. [7]

EMPLOYER BUDGET EXAMPLE

Can payroll-tax savings offset the administration fee?

Assume a hypothetical administrator charges a $100 setup fee plus $80 a month. The first-year fee is $100 + (12 × $80) = $1,060. If employees make $15,000 of eligible salary reductions and all those dollars would otherwise incur the employer’s full 7.65% Social Security and Medicare tax, estimated savings are $15,000 × 7.65% = $1,147.50.

That leaves $87.50 after the illustrated administration fee. These are example fees, not a vendor quote. Employer contributions, other charges, and the health FSA’s uniform-coverage reimbursement risk must also enter the budget. Tax savings do not guarantee that the arrangement pays for itself. [2]

The practical message is straightforward: paying an eligible expense through the FSA can cost less in take-home pay than paying the same expense with after-tax wages. That benefit is strongest when the employee chooses an amount that will actually be used.

The full annual health FSA election is available during coverage.

The uniform coverage rule creates one of the health FSA’s most valuable features. An employee does not have to wait until payroll deductions accumulate before receiving reimbursement up to the annual elected benefit. The expense must already have been incurred during the coverage period and meet the plan’s requirements, but the amount reimbursed can exceed the employee’s deductions to date.

CASH FLOW EXAMPLE

A January procedure and a full-year election

An employee elects $2,400 for the year, funded through $200 monthly salary reductions. In January, the employee incurs an eligible $1,800 expense. Assuming it is properly substantiated and no other claims have reduced the available benefit, the FSA can reimburse the full $1,800 even though only $200 has been withheld.

If the employee later leaves after receiving more in valid reimbursements than has been withheld, that difference does not become an ordinary loan the employee must repay. This is part of the employer’s health FSA risk.

This rule belongs to the health FSA. It does not require an HSA custodian to advance money that has not been deposited, and it does not make a dependent care FSA’s entire election available on the first day. An HRA also follows its own rules for when employer benefits become available. [1]

Eligible expenses extend beyond the medical insurance deductible.

Medical care under Section 213(d) includes qualifying diagnosis, treatment, and prevention expenses. Common examples include deductibles and copayments, dental treatment, eyeglasses and contact lenses, hearing aids, prescription drugs, and qualifying mental health treatment. Certain fertility treatment and medical travel expenses can qualify, subject to their particular rules.

Over-the-counter medicines can qualify without a prescription under the current rules, and menstrual care products are also eligible medical expenses. The old restriction on nonprescription medicines is no longer the current rule. General personal expenses, most cosmetic procedures, and health insurance premiums do not become health FSA expenses simply because an employee considers them health-related.

A health FSA can reimburse eligible expenses of the employee, spouse, qualifying dependents under the applicable modified tax definition, and the employee’s child who has not attained age 27 by the end of the tax year. This last rule is broader than the HSA rule we will discuss later. Plan terms still determine the benefit actually offered.

A debit card does not eliminate substantiation.

The administrator needs evidence of the expense, its amount, and when it was incurred, along with confirmation that it has not been reimbursed elsewhere. A qualifying electronic transaction, copayment match, or other approved method can satisfy substantiation without a separate receipt submission. A transaction merely occurring at a doctor’s office does not prove every required fact.

When substantiation is missing or a charge is ineligible, the plan must follow its correction process. That can include repayment requests, lawful recovery through compensation, offsets against later substantiated claims, and suspension of card access. Any uncollected amount needs proper handling. Simply deciding to add a charge to the employee’s W-2 is not a substitute for operating a compliant reimbursement process. [8]

CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · 1An employee has contributed $200 toward a $2,400 health FSA election and incurs a valid $1,800 claim. Is reimbursement limited to $200?

No. The uniform coverage rule makes the annual elected health FSA benefit available during the coverage period, reduced by prior reimbursements. The expense must still be incurred, eligible, and substantiated. This is different from an HSA or dependent care FSA.

A run-out period is not extra time to incur expenses.

A health FSA is generally subject to use-it-or-lose-it. That makes the election a budgeting decision, not an opportunity to put away as much as possible for an indefinite future. The employer may adopt a permitted grace period or carryover to reduce forfeitures, but neither feature is automatic.

Keep these terms separate in employee communications
TermWhat it doesWhat it does not do
Run-out periodAllows time to submit claims for expenses already incurred during an eligible coverage period.Does not, by itself, extend the date on which a new expense can be incurred.
Grace periodIf adopted, allows up to 2½ months after the plan year to incur eligible expenses using the prior year’s remaining amount.Does not provide unlimited rollover. It is not a universal fixed 75-day period.
CarryoverIf adopted, carries a permitted amount into the following health FSA plan year. The maximum for unused 2026 amounts is $680.Does not allow the same health FSA to have both a carryover and a grace period.

For a calendar-year plan with the maximum grace period, the additional expense-incurrence period ordinarily runs through March 15. Its claim-submission deadline is separately specified. A plan with only a run-out deadline of March 31 would not thereby cover a procedure performed in February; the run-out period is for submitting otherwise eligible claims.

A permitted health FSA carryover does not reduce the following year’s otherwise applicable salary-reduction maximum. The employer may allow less than the federal carryover maximum or choose neither carryover nor a grace period. Communicate the actual plan design rather than merely quoting what federal rules permit. [1] [4]

Election changes require both a permitted reason and plan authority.

Health FSA and premium elections are generally fixed for the plan year unless the law and the plan allow a change. A permitted change in status must satisfy the relevant consistency rules. An employee cannot simply raise the election after discovering an expensive procedure or cancel deductions because the benefit has already been used.

Different benefits have different change rules. A change allowed for dependent care because the care arrangement changes does not necessarily permit a health FSA change. HSA contribution elections have substantially more flexibility. Do not treat every account routed through Section 125 as if it had identical election restrictions.

Coordinate an FSA with the other accounts.

An FSA and HRA can coexist, but they cannot reimburse the same dollar of expense. Their documents should specify the order of payment. The HRA generally pays first under the default ordering rule; the arrangement can be designed so that the health FSA pays eligible expenses first. That can be useful when FSA amounts are subject to forfeiture. [9]

A general-purpose health FSA usually prevents HSA contributions because it can reimburse medical expenses before the required deductible. A limited-purpose FSA, generally designed for dental and vision benefits, or a properly designed post-deductible FSA can preserve HSA eligibility. A grace period or carryover can also extend disqualifying FSA coverage into the next year. Review the transition before moving employees into HSA coverage, rather than assuming December 31 always ends the issue.

After employment ends, claim-incurrence dates, run-out rights, and any applicable continuation rights matter. A reimbursement plan is not an individual savings account the employee can withdraw as cash. Module 6 will address continuation and other compliance obligations in more detail.

A dependent care account pays for care, not medical treatment.

A dependent care assistance program, often called a dependent care FSA, helps pay qualifying care expenses so the employee—and generally the spouse, if married—can work or look for work. The underlying exclusion comes from Section 129. It has a separate limit and a different purpose from the health FSA.

A qualifying person commonly is a dependent child under age 13. A spouse or other qualifying person who cannot care for themselves may also qualify if the applicable residence and dependency requirements are met. Adult care is therefore possible, but simply helping an older relative does not make every expense eligible.

Daycare, preschool, before- or after-school care, and qualifying day camps are common examples. The cost of kindergarten and higher-grade tuition is education, not qualifying dependent care. Overnight camp does not qualify. Care must meet the work-related rules; merely attending school does not create an unrestricted exclusion, although special earned-income rules apply to a full-time student spouse or a spouse incapable of self-care. [10]

The exclusion increased beginning in 2026.

The annual federal exclusion is $7,500 beginning in 2026, or $3,750 for a married individual filing separately. It remains $7,500 under current law for 2027 and is not automatically indexed. For a married couple filing jointly, coordinate both spouses’ benefits; it is not $7,500 for each spouse. Employer-provided assistance and employee salary reductions count together toward the applicable exclusion. The plan may offer a lower amount. [2]

The exclusion is also limited by earned income, including the lower-earning spouse’s income when applicable, and by eligible expenses. A high account election does not overcome those limits. An employee who looks for work but has no qualifying earned income for the year can face a different result than an employee who works throughout the year.

Reimbursement follows available funding and care already provided.

Unlike a health FSA, a dependent care FSA generally reimburses only up to the amount credited and available under the arrangement. If an employee elects $6,000 but has only $500 available, an eligible $800 claim may initially receive $500, with the remaining eligible amount reimbursed as funding becomes available under the plan’s procedures.

The care must have been provided. A deposit for next summer’s camp is not automatically reimbursable when paid in advance. But employees do not have to wait until an entire year of ongoing daycare ends: completed periods of care can be submitted as they occur. Debit-card administration is possible under the applicable substantiation rules; the account’s rules, not the presence of a card, control reimbursement.

Dependent care assistance also has its own nondiscrimination requirements. Report benefits in Form W-2, Box 10, and coordinate them with the employee’s Form 2441 calculation. Expenses excluded through the assistance program cannot also generate a duplicate child and dependent care tax credit. The comparison should reflect the household’s facts and the applicable year’s rules.

CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · 2A married couple filing jointly each elects $7,500 of dependent care assistance for 2026. Does having two employers create a $15,000 exclusion?

No. The couple generally shares the $7,500 annual exclusion. Employer assistance, both spouses’ elections, earned income, and eligible expenses must be coordinated. This differs from the separate employee salary-reduction limits that can apply to health FSAs.

An HRA pays according to the employer’s plan.

A health reimbursement arrangement allows the employer to reimburse specified medical expenses with favorable tax treatment. It is funded solely by the employer. Employees cannot add their own salary reductions, and an employer cannot convert the arrangement into an unrestricted cash benefit while keeping HRA treatment.

The employer defines the amount available, eligible participants, covered expenses, timing, and any carryover. Those choices remain subject to the applicable tax, market-reform, and nondiscrimination rules. “The employer designs it” does not mean there are no limits.

Tax status also affects participation. Self-employed individuals generally cannot receive HRA benefits as employees; sole proprietors, partners, and more-than-2% S corporation shareholders need the correct owner treatment. An employer’s ability to sponsor an HRA for staff does not establish the owner’s eligibility. As with cafeteria plans, an LLC’s tax classification matters.

Unlike an HSA deposit, an HRA credit ordinarily is not money transferred into an account the employee owns. The employer may pay reimbursements as valid claims arise rather than prefund every allowance. That is the cash-flow appeal of the arrangement: the employer promises to pay qualifying claims and retains amounts never required for reimbursement, subject to the plan’s continuing obligations.

Begin with the conventional HRA integrated with group coverage.

For the usual active-employee HRA integrated with a group medical plan, the employer offers qualifying group coverage and the HRA participant must actually be enrolled in qualifying group coverage. That coverage can, under the integration rules and plan terms, be a spouse’s employer plan rather than the sponsoring employer’s own plan.

The distinction from a health FSA is important. For the typical excepted-benefit health FSA, the relevant employer group coverage must be available. For a conventional integrated HRA, actual enrollment is part of the integration requirements. Family members whose expenses the HRA covers also need to satisfy the applicable integration rules; an employee’s self-only enrollment does not automatically support a general family HRA. [11] [12]

The permitted reimbursement scope depends partly on the integration method. Integration with a minimum-value group plan can support broader medical reimbursement; the alternative method limits the types of expenses reimbursed. Required opt-out rights also matter. This is why the administrator needs the actual plan information and enrollment rules, not merely a statement that “everyone has insurance.”

There is no general statutory dollar cap for a conventional group-integrated HRA. But that statement does not apply to every HRA type: QSEHRAs and excepted benefit HRAs have their own annual limits. Individual coverage HRAs, retiree-only arrangements, and other specialized designs follow their own rules.

Define precisely what the HRA reimburses.

A plan might reimburse deductible expenses only, specified coinsurance, or a broader range of Section 213(d) medical expenses. It may restrict reimbursement to in-network claims. It may have different employee-only and family allowances, subject to the applicable requirements. It may permit unused amounts to carry forward or limit the benefit to the current period.

The claim process must match the design. If the HRA reimburses only coinsurance after the deductible, a receipt showing that someone paid a provider is not enough to determine the benefit. The administrator may need the medical plan’s explanation of benefits to establish what applied to the deductible, what was coinsurance, and whether the service was in network.

As with an FSA, eligible family relationships and actual plan coverage must be checked. A domestic partner is not automatically eligible for tax-free reimbursement, while the special rule for an employee’s child under age 27 at year-end can apply to an HRA. Neither relationship rules nor the plan document eliminates the integration requirements.

The same $500 promise can produce different results.

Consider a $2,500 deductible paired with a $500 HRA. The employee’s maximum net deductible responsibility can be $2,000 under several designs. The timing of the reimbursement, however, changes both the employee’s experience and how often the employer pays.

Three ways to place a $500 HRA within a $2,500 deductible
DesignOrder of deductible paymentsPractical effect
UpfrontHRA pays the first $500; employee pays the next $2,000.Employees receive help immediately. More participants may use the full HRA.
MiddleEmployee pays $1,000; HRA pays $500; employee pays the remaining $1,000.Assistance begins after some initial employee responsibility.
Back endEmployee pays the first $2,000; HRA pays the final $500.The employer reimburses only employees whose eligible expenses reach that layer.

The back-end arrangement can preserve some employee cost awareness while helping those with larger claims. It does not guarantee savings. The result depends on premiums, actual claims, administration fees, enrollment, and the terms of the reimbursement promise.

It also does not automatically preserve HSA eligibility. A $2,000 threshold exceeds the ordinary 2026 self-only HDHP minimum deductible of $1,700, but it is below the $3,400 family minimum. The underlying medical plan and the HRA must both satisfy the relevant rules. The same dollar threshold cannot be declared HSA-compatible for every coverage tier.

The historical 70-employee case

In this historical case, the employer moved from a $500 deductible to a $1,000 deductible and promised to reimburse the second $500. That kept the employee’s net deductible at $500. However, coinsurance, copayments, and other out-of-pocket terms also changed. An HRA that offsets the deductible does not necessarily recreate every benefit of the prior insurance policy.

Historical illustration: the annual employer budget
ItemAnnual amount
Prior annual premium budget$377,873
New insurance premium$323,775
Difference available for HRA claims and administration$54,098
Illustrated HRA claims and administration$15,159
Illustrated net savings$38,939

The arithmetic is $377,873 − $323,775 − $15,159 = $38,939, approximately 10.3% of the original annual premium budget.

CHECK THE EMPLOYEE’S WHOLE EXPOSURE

The deductible can stay the same while total cost sharing rises.

Suppose the prior plan has a $500 deductible plus up to $1,500 in additional coinsurance: $2,000 of combined exposure. The replacement has a $1,000 deductible plus up to $3,000 in additional coinsurance. With a $500 HRA reimbursement, the employee’s net exposure for those items is $1,000 + $3,000 − $500 = $3,500.

The net deductible remains $500, but the combined amount is $1,500 higher. This illustration assumes the stated coinsurance amounts are in addition to the deductibles and the full HRA is available for these expenses. Compare any copays, uncovered services, network differences, and other limits separately.

When presenting a new proposal, build the employer’s maximum exposure as well as an expected-cost estimate. If the obligation truly is capped at $500 for each of 70 participants, maximum reimbursement exposure is $35,000 before administrative fees. Family allowances, carryovers, or other covered benefits can change that calculation. An attractive average result is not a substitute for budgeting the actual commitment.

REUSABLE COMPARISON

Compare the new premium plus HRA reimbursements plus administration with the current premium. Then compare the employee’s full benefit design, including expenses the HRA does not reimburse.

CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · 3An employer adds a $500 HRA to offset a $500 deductible increase. Has it necessarily preserved the entire prior benefit?

No. The deductible may feel the same after reimbursement, but coinsurance, copays, networks, covered services, and out-of-pocket limits may differ. The HRA’s claim rules and the employee’s cash-flow needs also matter.

Individual coverage reimbursement requires a qualifying structure.

The group-integrated HRA is not the only option. Several arrangements allow different coverage relationships. They should be identified by their actual requirements rather than treated as permission for an employer to reimburse any individual premium informally.

QSEHRA: a defined option for eligible small employers

A qualified small employer HRA is available to an eligible employer that is not an applicable large employer and does not offer a group health plan to its employees. A health FSA can count as a group health plan for this restriction, so “we do not offer medical insurance” is not the entire eligibility analysis.

The QSEHRA is employer-funded and generally must be provided on the same terms to eligible employees, subject to permitted exclusions and variations. It can reimburse eligible medical expenses, including individual premiums, under its terms. Minimum essential coverage is required for tax-free reimbursement.

The 2026 maximum permitted benefit is $6,450 for self-only coverage or $13,100 for family coverage, with applicable proration for partial-year eligibility. These are statutory ceilings on the arrangement, not amounts every employer must contribute. Confirm the official IRS adjustment before setting a 2027 QSEHRA allowance. [2] [13]

A QSEHRA affects Marketplace premium tax credits. If it is affordable under the applicable test, it can eliminate eligibility for the credit. If it is unaffordable, the otherwise available credit is generally reduced by the applicable permitted benefit. It is therefore inaccurate to say that a QSEHRA always just offsets a credit or that an employee can simply waive it to receive an unreduced credit.

ICHRA: individual coverage for employers of any size

An individual coverage HRA has been available since 2020. HealthCare.gov currently uses the name CHOICE Arrangement for this structure. ICHRA remains the terminology used in the underlying regulations; both names refer to the individual coverage reimbursement structure discussed here.

An ICHRA can be offered by an employer of any size. Employees and covered dependents must maintain qualifying individual health insurance or permitted Medicare coverage for the applicable months. A short-term policy, a sharing arrangement, or a spouse’s group plan does not simply substitute for the required individual coverage.

The employer can offer a traditional group plan to one permitted employee class and an ICHRA to another, subject to class rules and any minimum class-size requirements. It generally cannot give employees in the same class a free choice between its traditional group plan and its ICHRA. Within a class, the same-terms rules apply, with permitted variations such as age and family size. There is no general federal annual contribution cap comparable to the QSEHRA cap. [14] [15]

An affordable ICHRA offer can block a Marketplace premium tax credit even when the employee declines it. If the ICHRA is unaffordable, the employee generally must opt out to claim a credit for which the household otherwise qualifies. An employee enrolled in the ICHRA cannot also receive a credit for the same coverage month.

Two affordability tests that should not be mixed up
ArrangementIndividual-market benchmark for the employee testTax-credit interaction
QSEHRASelf-only second-lowest-cost silver plan, less the applicable self-only permitted benefit.An affordable QSEHRA can block the credit; an unaffordable QSEHRA generally reduces an otherwise available credit.
ICHRASelf-only lowest-cost silver plan available to the employee, less the applicable ICHRA amount.An affordable offer can block the credit; an unaffordable offer generally requires opting out to receive a credit.

An ALE can use an appropriately designed ICHRA to address its employer shared responsibility obligations, but the offer, affordability analysis, and reporting still need to satisfy the applicable rules. The employer’s safe-harbor calculation and the Marketplace’s household-income calculation serve different purposes, as discussed in Module 3.

For an eligible off-Marketplace individual policy, an employer may also permit employees to pay the portion of premiums not reimbursed by the ICHRA through an appropriate Section 125 arrangement. Marketplace policy premiums cannot be paid through that pre-tax salary-reduction route. Offering an ICHRA can create a special enrollment opportunity, but notices, effective dates, and employee enrollment still need to be coordinated.

Excepted benefit, retiree-only, and HSA-compatible designs

An excepted benefit HRA has a limit on amounts newly made available: $2,200 for plan years beginning in 2026 and $2,250 for 2027. The employer must offer qualifying group coverage, although the employee need not enroll in it. The arrangement must satisfy its other conditions and generally cannot reimburse individual major-medical premiums, group-plan premiums other than COBRA or other continuation coverage, or Medicare premiums. It can reimburse certain other medical expenses and excepted-benefit premiums under the rules. [6] [16] [17]

A retiree-only HRA follows a different market-reform exception. Medicare reimbursement arrangements also require careful attention to their design and Medicare secondary payer rules. Their existence does not make every active-employee reimbursement arrangement permissible.

Finally, limited-purpose and post-deductible describe benefit restrictions that can preserve HSA contribution eligibility. Those restrictions may be built into appropriate arrangements; the label alone is not proof. A premium-only ICHRA or QSEHRA can have a different HSA result from one that also pays first-dollar medical expenses. Review what the arrangement can reimburse.

The health plan creates eligibility. The HSA holds the money.

An HSA strategy normally has two parts: qualifying health coverage and an individual savings account. Enrolling in a qualifying medical plan does not automatically establish or fund the account. Conversely, having an HSA balance does not prove that the owner remains eligible to make new contributions.

The conventional qualifying coverage is a high deductible health plan as defined by Section 223. “HSA-qualified plan” is often the more useful description for employees because a plan with a large deductible is not necessarily an HDHP under the tax rules. The design must also meet the applicable out-of-pocket limit and restrictions on benefits before the deductible.

Published HSA and ordinary HDHP amounts
Item2026 self-only2026 family2027 self-only2027 family
HSA annual contribution limit$4,400$8,750$4,500$9,000
HDHP minimum deductible$1,700$3,400$1,750$3,500
HDHP maximum out-of-pocket expense$8,500$17,000$8,700$17,400
Additional age-55 catch-up$1,000 for each eligible account holder, deposited into that person’s own HSA; subject to eligibility rules.

Sources: IRS Revenue Procedures 2025-19 and 2026-24. The special individual bronze/catastrophic rule is discussed next. [16] [17]

Do not interchange the contribution limit, the minimum deductible, and the maximum out-of-pocket expense. The first controls deposits to the HSA. The other two are health-plan design standards. Premiums are not part of the HDHP out-of-pocket maximum. For plans using a provider network, the statutory maximum generally addresses in-network expenses; out-of-network treatment needs separate attention.

Ordinary HDHP coverage generally starts after the deductible.

Under the ordinary rules, nonpreventive medical and prescription benefits generally cannot begin before the required deductible is met. The employee can still receive the network’s negotiated price. A $200 contracted office visit might be paid entirely by the employee and credited to the deductible, rather than handled through an upfront $30 copay.

That does not mean every charge a person pays reduces the deductible. The insurance plan decides which covered expenses accumulate. A qualified HSA expense can be outside the medical policy’s benefits. For example, HSA money may pay for eligible eyeglasses without those dollars counting toward the medical plan’s deductible.

Permitted preventive care can be covered before the deductible. IRS guidance also permits specified care for certain chronic conditions and other statutory exceptions. Whether the plan must cover a preventive service without cost sharing under the ACA and whether coverage is permitted before the deductible for HSA purposes are related but distinct questions. Review the actual plan terms. [1]

Embedded and aggregate family deductibles

An embedded deductible gives each covered person an individual deductible within a larger family deductible. An aggregate deductible requires the family deductible to be satisfied before ordinary post-deductible benefits begin. These terms describe the deductible; they do not erase separate requirements that may apply to an individual’s out-of-pocket maximum.

Under the ordinary HDHP rules, a family plan cannot begin paying nonexcepted benefits for one member before at least the statutory family minimum deductible has been satisfied. In 2026, an embedded $3,000 individual deductible that causes the plan to begin paying would be below the $3,400 family minimum, even if the overall family deductible were $6,000. An embedded $3,500 deductible would clear that particular 2026 minimum test, but the rest of the plan still needs review.

This is why “the individual deductible meets the self-only minimum” is not enough when the employee actually has family coverage. The family minimum matters for embedded benefits under family coverage. The newly enacted individual bronze and catastrophic exception changes the analysis for qualifying plans in that category, as explained below.

Three newer rules broaden HSA-compatible coverage.

The 2025 legislation commonly called the One Big Beautiful Bill Act changed several HSA rules. The IRS explains these provisions in Notice 2026-5. They are important qualifications to older shorthand such as “nothing except preventive care can be covered before the deductible.”

Telehealth and other remote care

For plan years beginning after 2024, qualifying telehealth and other remote care may be covered before the deductible without causing the plan or individual to fail the HSA rules on that basis. This relief is permanent under current law. It permits qualifying coverage; it does not require every plan to add the benefit.

The exception is not a blanket exemption for all services connected to a virtual visit. In-person care, equipment, and prescription drugs furnished in connection with telehealth do not automatically receive the same treatment.

Individual bronze and catastrophic plans

Beginning January 1, 2026, qualifying bronze and catastrophic plans available as individual coverage through an Exchange are treated as HDHPs even when they do not meet the ordinary deductible or out-of-pocket tests. This is an individual-market provision. A bronze small-group or SHOP plan does not qualify solely because it is bronze.

Purchasing through the Exchange itself is not always required. The IRS guidance covers qualifying off-Exchange versions and provides relief when an individual buying individual-market bronze or catastrophic coverage has no reason to believe it is unavailable on an Exchange. The other personal HSA eligibility conditions still apply.

An ICHRA used to buy an eligible bronze plan also needs separate review. The policy may qualify, but an HRA that reimburses first-dollar medical expenses can still be disqualifying other coverage. A premium-only reimbursement design can produce a different result.

Direct primary care arrangements

Starting in 2026, a qualifying direct primary care service arrangement can coexist with HSA contribution eligibility when aggregate fees stay within the applicable monthly limit: $150 for one individual or $300 when the arrangement covers more than one individual. The published limits remain $150 and $300 for 2027. The statute provides for indexing after 2026, but indexing does not necessarily increase the amount every year.

The arrangement must meet the statutory design requirements. The fixed periodic fee must be the sole compensation for the primary care provided under the arrangement. The definition excludes procedures requiring general anesthesia, prescription drugs other than vaccines, and laboratory services not typically provided in an ambulatory primary care setting. Calling a membership “DPC” does not establish that it qualifies.

CONTRIBUTING AND SPENDING ARE DIFFERENT TESTS

A qualifying DPC arrangement’s fees can be eligible for payment from an HSA even if they exceed the monthly fee ceiling. Exceeding that ceiling can nevertheless disqualify the individual from making HSA contributions while enrolled. The dollar ceiling limits the contribution-eligibility exception; it is not the same rule as the distribution exception.

Employer-paid DPC fees cannot also be reimbursed to the employee from an HSA. Also, separately paid DPC membership fees do not count toward the HDHP deductible merely because they are HSA-eligible expenses. [18] [17]

You do not have to be the primary insured to own an HSA.

The policyholder and the HSA account holder do not have to be the same person. A spouse covered under the employee’s qualifying family plan can open an HSA if the spouse satisfies the eligibility rules. An otherwise eligible adult child covered on a parent’s family plan may also establish an account.

For a typical month, an individual must have qualifying coverage on the first day of the month, have no disqualifying other health coverage, not be enrolled in Medicare, and not be someone another taxpayer is entitled to claim as a dependent. The dependency test is not solved merely by asking whether the parent actually chose to claim the person. [1]

Federal HSA eligibility has no separate minimum-age requirement. Dependency rules eliminate many minors in practice, and financial institutions have their own account-opening requirements. An insured adult child can remain on a parent’s policy while no longer being a tax dependent, which makes the separate eligibility analysis especially important.

Health-plan family status and tax dependency answer different questions.

A 24-year-old may qualify to stay on a parent’s health plan but fail the tax-dependent definition used for the parent’s HSA distributions. In that case, the parent cannot assume that the child’s medical bills qualify for tax-free payment from the parent’s HSA. The special under-age-27 reimbursement rule for FSAs and HRAs does not extend to HSAs.

If that adult child is independently HSA-eligible and has family HDHP coverage, the child may have their own family contribution limit. The special rule requiring spouses to share a family limit is a married-couple rule, not a requirement that every eligible adult on the same family policy divide one limit. Actual eligibility, tax dependency, and coverage months still need to be established.

Spouses may use one account or two, but there is no joint HSA.

Each HSA belongs to one individual. Eligible spouses can each establish an account, or they can allocate their shared family base contribution to one spouse’s account. When the married-couple family rule applies, opening two accounts does not double the base annual limit.

FULL-YEAR 2026 EXAMPLE

Two eligible spouses, both age 55 or older

Assume both spouses are HSA-eligible all year and the family contribution rule applies. They can divide the $8,750 family base limit between their accounts by agreement. Each can also contribute a $1,000 catch-up, but each catch-up must go into that spouse’s own HSA.

The combined potential contribution is $10,750. They cannot put both catch-ups into one spouse’s account. Employer contributions and contributions from other sources count toward the applicable limits.

CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · 4A spouse has qualifying coverage through the employee’s family policy. Must the employee be the person who opens the HSA?

No. The spouse can own an HSA if independently eligible. HSA ownership does not require being the primary insured. Married spouses must still coordinate their shared family base limit, and each spouse’s catch-up belongs in that spouse’s own account.

A second benefit can change HSA eligibility.

An employee may enroll in the employer’s HSA-qualified plan and still be ineligible to contribute. Common problems include enrollment in a spouse’s non-HDHP medical plan, Medicare, Medicaid, or a general-purpose FSA or HRA that can reimburse the employee’s medical expenses before the required deductible.

Being offered another plan is different from being covered by it. An employer can offer a traditional plan alongside an HDHP. An employee who elects only the HDHP does not lose eligibility merely because the traditional option was available. Similarly, a spouse can have separate non-HDHP coverage that does not cover the employee.

The spouse’s FSA is an easy issue to miss.

A spouse’s general-purpose health FSA often can reimburse the employee’s expenses even if the employee is not enrolled in the spouse’s medical policy. That reimbursement coverage can disqualify the employee from HSA contributions. Choosing not to use the FSA does not remove coverage that the plan provides.

A properly limited-purpose or post-deductible arrangement can be compatible. The restriction must be in the actual coverage terms, and the post-deductible threshold must meet the applicable statutory requirement. A casual promise not to submit claims is not the same as changing the benefit. Plan administrators should also check any general-purpose FSA carryover or grace period when employees move to HSA coverage. [19]

Some additional coverage is permitted.

Dental, vision, accident, disability, and qualifying long-term care coverage generally do not prevent HSA eligibility. Permitted insurance also includes certain specified-disease and fixed hospital-indemnity designs. A medical gap policy that reimburses actual deductible expenses is not automatically permitted merely because it is called supplemental insurance.

Employee assistance and wellness programs require attention to what they provide; programs that do not provide significant medical benefits can fit the permitted rules. The newer telehealth and qualifying DPC exceptions expand the available options, but each exception has conditions.

Medicare enrollment matters; age alone does not.

Turning 65 does not automatically prohibit HSA contributions if the individual remains otherwise eligible and is not enrolled in Medicare. Enrollment in Part A or Part B does. Retroactive Medicare coverage can also change the contribution calculation for earlier months, so employees approaching retirement should coordinate the effective date before continuing payroll contributions. [20]

Once enrolled in Medicare, the person still owns the HSA and can use its existing funds. The loss of contribution eligibility does not make qualified distributions taxable. Nor does it necessarily prevent a deposit made later for a year or month in which the individual was eligible, if the contribution deadline and limit are satisfied.

VA benefits need a more precise explanation than “90 days.”

Receiving certain VA medical benefits during the preceding three months can affect HSA contribution eligibility. But the rule has exceptions for disregarded coverage, preventive care, and care for service-connected disabilities. IRS guidance also provides an administrative rule for veterans with a VA disability rating. Do not describe all veterans, or every VA visit, as automatically disqualifying. [12]

The practical enrollment questions are: What coverage do you have? What other arrangement can reimburse your expenses? When does that coverage begin or end? Those questions are more useful than asking only whether the employee selected the plan labeled “HSA.”

Employer money counts toward the HSA maximum.

An eligible individual, employer, family member, or another person may contribute to an HSA. The source of the deposit does not create an additional annual allowance. Contributions across all HSAs belonging to the same individual must be coordinated.

For example, an employee eligible for the full 2026 self-only limit has a $4,400 base maximum. If the employer contributes $1,000, only $3,400 remains for additional base contributions from the employee and other sources. An eligible catch-up can increase that person’s limit, but the ordinary employer deposit does not sit outside it.

If parents contribute to an eligible adult child’s HSA, the deduction generally belongs to the child as account holder, not the parents. The child still needs the proper eligibility and must include that deposit in the annual total. An HSA does not require earned income in the way an IRA does, but it does require HSA eligibility.

Full-year eligibility is the easy calculation.

Someone eligible for all 12 months with the same coverage category can generally use the full self-only or family amount, subject to married-couple coordination. If the person turns 55 during the year and is eligible all year, the full $1,000 catch-up can apply; it is not prorated merely because the birthday occurs late in the year.

When eligibility or coverage category changes, calculate the monthly amounts. Use the coverage and eligibility on the first day of each month, add one-twelfth of the applicable annual amount for each eligible month, and include the applicable catch-up calculation.

2026 illustrations without using the last-month rule
SituationCalculationBase contribution limit
Self-only eligibility January–June; ineligible July–December$4,400 × 6/12$2,200
Self-only January–June; family July–December; eligible all year($4,400 × 6/12) + ($8,750 × 6/12)$6,575
Family eligibility October–December only$8,750 × 3/12$2,187.50

The last-month rule can allow more—with a testing period.

An individual eligible on December 1 can potentially use the last-month rule to contribute based on that coverage category as though eligible for the full year. The tradeoff is a testing period that begins on December 1 of that year and continues through December 31 of the following year for a calendar-year taxpayer.

In the October–December family example, the individual could potentially contribute the full $8,750 for 2026 instead of $2,187.50. The extra amount attributable to the rule is $6,562.50. If the individual fails to remain eligible during the testing period, other than because of death or disability, that additional amount is included in income in the year of failure and generally faces a 10% additional tax. In this illustration, that additional tax would be $656.25.

The employee can avoid relying on the testing period by using the ordinary monthly calculation instead. That may be appropriate when a known coverage change, retirement, or Medicare enrollment makes continued eligibility uncertain. The right choice depends on facts the employee may not have discussed at the enrollment meeting. [1]

Deposits can be made later than the month of eligibility.

HSA contributions generally can be made through the original federal income tax return due date for the contribution year, without counting filing extensions. The date is often April 15, but weekends, holidays, and applicable relief can change the actual deadline. Tell the custodian which tax year a prior-year deposit is for.

An individual who loses eligibility in July may still make a later contribution for eligible January–June months within the permitted deadline. Losing eligibility stops the accrual of additional eligible months; it does not automatically forbid every later deposit. Also, a contribution made after a medical bill can support reimbursement if the expense was incurred after the HSA was established and the other requirements are met.

CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · 5Someone first becomes HSA-eligible with family coverage on October 1, 2026. Can you simply tell them their limit is $8,750?

Not without explaining the choice. The ordinary three-month limit is $2,187.50. The last-month rule may permit $8,750 if the December 1 conditions are satisfied, but it creates a testing period through December 31, 2027. All contributors’ deposits count toward the chosen limit.

Pre-tax payroll and a personal tax deduction are different routes.

An employee who makes an eligible direct HSA contribution generally claims an above-the-line federal income tax deduction. Itemizing is not required. But making a personal deposit does not ordinarily refund Social Security and Medicare taxes already paid on the wages used to fund it.

Eligible salary reductions through a properly established Section 125 plan generally avoid both federal income and applicable payroll taxes. This can benefit the employee and save the employer its matching payroll tax. State tax treatment can differ from federal treatment, so a federal tax illustration should not be presented as a universal state result.

Employer contributions and employee salary reductions made through the cafeteria plan are reported as employer HSA contributions for federal tax reporting, generally in Form W-2, Box 12, code W. They do not also generate a second personal HSA deduction. The employee’s own direct deposits are handled separately when completing Form 8889. [2]

HSA elections are more flexible than health FSA elections.

Employees must be allowed to change HSA salary-reduction elections prospectively at least monthly under the cafeteria-plan guidance. They can increase, reduce, start, or stop future contributions, subject to eligibility and limits. That flexibility does not automatically allow them to change their underlying medical insurance election.

Employers can establish the timing of their own HSA contributions, such as a lump sum or periodic deposits, subject to the applicable rules. A promised annual employer contribution should not be mistaken for money already available to pay a claim. If the account has only $300 deposited, the HSA does not owe the employee the rest of a future contribution schedule in advance.

Employer contributions have their own fairness rules.

Contributions outside a cafeteria plan generally are subject to the HSA comparability rules for comparable participating employees. Contributions through a cafeteria plan instead are subject to Section 125 nondiscrimination rules. The employer does not get to choose whichever test produces the easiest result after the deposits are made.

A matching contribution tied to employee HSA contributions can be structured through a cafeteria plan, subject to its rules. It should not be assumed to satisfy the separate comparability requirements outside that framework. Document the funding approach before promising different contribution formulas to different groups. [20]

The employer can generally select the custodian it uses for its payroll and employer deposits. Once properly deposited, the money belongs to the employee. The employee can keep it, use it, or transfer it under the HSA rules; it is not ordinarily an employer-controlled reimbursement budget.

Business owners excluded from Section 125 are not thereby barred from HSAs. An otherwise eligible sole proprietor, partner, or more-than-2% S corporation shareholder can have an HSA, but the contribution and tax-reporting route differs from an eligible employee’s pre-tax payroll route. LLC tax classification and ownership attribution again matter.

An eligible medical bill does not have to be reimbursed immediately.

An HSA can pay qualified medical expenses of the account holder, spouse, and qualifying dependents under the HSA’s modified tax-dependent definition. The spouse or dependent does not have to be covered by the account holder’s HDHP for an otherwise eligible expense to qualify. The account holder must still verify the relationship and expense.

Common expenses include eligible medical cost sharing, dental care, vision care, hearing services, and other Section 213(d) expenses. Over-the-counter medicines and menstrual care products qualify under current rules. Insurance coverage and HSA expense eligibility are different questions: the HSA may pay an eligible service that the medical policy does not cover.

The establishment date is critical.

Qualified expenses generally must be incurred after the HSA is established. Starting qualifying insurance on January 1 does not automatically make a January bill eligible for reimbursement from an account first established in March. State law determines when the HSA is established, and special rules can apply to transfers and rollovers. Confirm the date instead of treating insurance enrollment as account creation.

Once an eligible expense is incurred after establishment, there is generally no federal time limit requiring immediate HSA reimbursement. The account holder can pay with after-tax cash, preserve the documentation, and reimburse themselves later—even in a later year—provided the expense was not reimbursed elsewhere and was not claimed as an itemized medical deduction.

KEEP THE RECEIPT WITH THE REASON

A $900 dental bill paid outside the HSA

Assume the HSA was already established, the treatment qualifies, and the account holder pays $900 personally in 2026. The account holder can leave the HSA funds invested or saved and later take a $900 tax-free reimbursement supported by the retained records.

The same bill cannot support a later FSA reimbursement, an insurance reimbursement, an itemized deduction, and a tax-free HSA reimbursement for the same dollars.

Paying out of pocket to preserve HSA savings is an option, not a requirement. Employees who need the HSA to pay current bills can use it now. Investment options may help long-term savings, but investment values can fall and money needed soon should be considered differently from long-term reserves.

Most insurance premiums are not HSA expenses—but there are exceptions.

Do not tell an employee that any health premium can be paid from an HSA tax-free. The main exceptions include:

  • Qualified long-term care insurance premiums, within the applicable age-based annual limits.
  • Health continuation coverage, such as COBRA premiums.
  • Health coverage while receiving federal or state unemployment compensation, under the applicable rules.
  • Medicare and other qualifying health coverage after the HSA owner reaches age 65, excluding Medigap premiums. A younger account holder cannot use this age-65 exception merely because a spouse is older.

The newer DPC fee provision discussed earlier is another specific rule. Its existence does not make all membership fees or insurance premiums eligible. Also, a premium or medical expense already paid by an employer on a tax-free basis cannot be reimbursed again from the employee’s HSA. [1] [18] [20]

Tax-free treatment depends on what the distribution pays.

An HSA’s commonly described triple federal tax benefit consists of favorable contribution treatment, tax-free earnings while held in the account, and tax-free distributions for qualified medical expenses. A nonqualified withdrawal does not receive that third benefit.

Before age 65, a nonqualified distribution generally is included in income and faces a 20% additional tax. After age 65, the 20% additional tax no longer applies, but a nonqualified distribution is still included in income. The additional-tax exception also applies after disability or death under the relevant rules.

DISTRIBUTION EXAMPLE

An account holder withdraws $500 and can support only $300 as qualified unreimbursed medical expenses. Assuming no other exclusion applies, the remaining $200 is taxable income. If the owner is under 65 and no exception applies, the additional tax is $200 × 20% = $40.

Three percentages refer to three different problems.

Do not mix up these HSA tax rules
IssuePotential consequenceWhat to check
Excess contributionGenerally a 6% excise tax while an uncorrected excess remains, subject to the statutory calculation.Eligibility months, all contributions, and timely return of excess plus attributable earnings.
Failure of the last-month-rule testing periodIncome inclusion and generally a 10% additional tax on the amount attributable to that rule.Testing-period eligibility and the death/disability exception.
Nonqualified distributionIncome inclusion and generally a 20% additional tax before age 65, unless an exception applies.Expense eligibility, establishment date, duplicate reimbursement, age, and disability.

For an excess contribution, the account holder should work with the custodian on the proper return-of-excess procedure. The correction deadline generally includes extensions of the return due date, unlike the ordinary deadline for making an HSA contribution. Attributable earnings require separate tax treatment. Simply taking an ordinary debit-card withdrawal is not necessarily the proper correction.

Keep evidence, not just a bank statement.

The employer and HSA custodian generally do not adjudicate each medical claim as an FSA or HRA administrator would. The account holder must keep records showing what the expense was, when it was incurred, whose care it covered, and that it was not reimbursed or deducted elsewhere.

A useful record set includes the itemized receipt or explanation of benefits, proof of payment, and a note showing whether the expense has already been reimbursed from the HSA. Digital copies help preserve documents that may fade or be needed years later. A bank statement showing a withdrawal does not by itself establish a qualified medical expense.

Form 8889 generally reports HSA contributions and distributions, including employer contributions and any taxable amounts. The custodian’s Form 1099-SA and Form 5498-SA and the employer’s W-2 provide information used in that process. A person who does not itemize deductions may still need Form 8889.

Changing jobs does not change who owns the account.

An employee leaving the company keeps the HSA balance. The funds can continue to pay qualified expenses even if the former employee switches to a non-HDHP or enrolls in Medicare. New contributions depend on eligibility and available contribution room; spending existing funds does not require continued HDHP enrollment.

Choose a beneficiary. If the spouse is the designated beneficiary, the account becomes the spouse’s HSA. For a nonspouse beneficiary, the account stops being an HSA at death and its fair market value generally becomes taxable to that beneficiary in the year of death. If the estate is the beneficiary, the value is included on the decedent’s final return. A nonestate beneficiary’s taxable amount can be reduced by qualifying expenses of the decedent paid within one year. This is a tax-reporting result, not a promise that the government automatically withholds a fixed share and sends the rest as cash. [1]

An HSA option is not only for people who rarely use care.

Compare low, medium, and high expected use of health care: each produces different tradeoffs. Someone who rarely uses care may prefer a lower premium and an HSA balance that remains available next year. Someone who expects to reach an out-of-pocket maximum may care more about the combined premium and maximum exposure than the presence of office-visit copays.

For employees in the middle, the answer may be less obvious. Several recurring visits or expensive prescriptions can create significant costs before the deductible. Compare actual plan terms, the relevant negotiated prices, employer funding, and tax effects. “HSA plans are always cheaper” is not a reliable recommendation.

A useful annual comparison starts with employee premium contributions plus expected covered out-of-pocket expenses, then accounts for employer money available to offset those expenses and the applicable tax savings. Also show a high-cost scenario and explain what lies outside the in-network out-of-pocket maximum. Do not subtract an employee’s own HSA deposit as though it were free employer money; it remains part of the employee’s compensation or personal funds.

Annual value and immediate affordability are different.

A plan can look favorable over a full year but still be difficult for an employee who faces a large January bill. An upfront employer HSA contribution, an HRA reimbursement schedule, or a health FSA’s uniform coverage feature can change that cash-flow experience.

The same employer contribution also feels different depending on the account. A $1,000 HSA deposit belongs to the employee once properly contributed. A $1,000 HRA allowance may produce no payment if the employee incurs no reimbursable claims. Neither is inherently wrong, but employees should understand what the employer is promising.

Match the explanation to the benefit: use an FSA for deliberate annual expense planning, an HRA for an employer-designed reimbursement promise, and an HSA for eligible individuals who want current medical purchasing power and continuing ownership. Some employees can appropriately use more than one account when the designs are coordinated.

The account needs an operating process, not just a name.

Employers often outsource FSA and HRA administration because the work includes plan setup, elections, substantiation, reimbursement, deadlines, and data handling. A capable third-party administrator helps carry out the process. The employer still needs accurate eligibility data, correct payroll deductions, timely funding, and a clear allocation of responsibilities.

Nondiscrimination testing is not one universal test. Section 125 addresses cafeteria-plan eligibility, contributions, and benefits, including a key-employee concentration rule. Health FSAs and self-insured medical reimbursement arrangements also raise Section 105(h) issues. Dependent care assistance has separate Section 129 requirements. The 25% key-employee concentration rule is one component, not a substitute for the other tests.

For HSA employer contributions, determine whether comparability or Section 125 nondiscrimination applies. An HSA has a trust or custodial agreement, but it generally does not require an employer reimbursement-plan document of the kind used for an FSA or HRA. The employer still needs the appropriate cafeteria-plan document for pre-tax salary reductions and the required documents for its medical plan.

A practical division of responsibilities
TaskFSA / HRAHSA
Define the benefitEmployer establishes a compliant written reimbursement arrangement and related plan documents.Individual establishes the account; employer defines any payroll or employer contribution program.
Confirm coverage relationshipsCheck FSA excepted-benefit design, HRA integration, and any HSA-compatible restrictions.Check qualifying coverage and the individual’s other coverage, Medicare, and dependency status.
Pay medical claimsAdministrator applies plan terms and substantiates expenses.Owner uses available account funds and maintains supporting tax records.
Handle year-endApply elections, limits, deadlines, permitted carryover/grace features, and testing.Coordinate contributions, eligibility months, tax forms, and any corrections.

Privacy, ERISA, continuation coverage, notices, and reporting can apply depending on the arrangement. Share only the information each party needs to perform its role. A payroll team needs deduction information; it does not automatically need the details of every employee’s diagnosis or claim. Module 6 will return to the employer’s broader compliance responsibilities.

WHAT TO RETAIN

Five questions organize the entire module.

  1. Who puts the money in? Employee elections, employer-only reimbursement promises, and combined HSA contributions have different rules.
  2. When can it be used? A health FSA’s full annual benefit is different from a funded HSA balance or dependent care reimbursement availability.
  3. What coverage must exist? An offer of group coverage, actual enrollment, and individual HSA eligibility are separate tests.
  4. Who keeps what is unused? FSA forfeiture rules, HRA plan terms, and HSA ownership create different incentives.
  5. Who must prove the expense? FSA/HRA substantiation and the HSA owner’s tax records are different administrative systems.
CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING · 6An employee leaves the company with $1,000 in an HSA and an unused $1,000 HRA allowance. Can both amounts simply be transferred to the employee’s checking account tax-free?

No. The employee owns the HSA, but tax-free distributions generally require qualified medical expenses. The HRA is an employer reimbursement arrangement; any remaining rights follow its terms and applicable continuation rules, and it cannot provide an unrestricted tax-free cash-out.

You now have the account-based part of the benefits package. The next module broadens the discussion to ancillary and supplemental products: benefits that address needs beyond the major-medical plan and help employees see the value of the overall offer.

Sources and annual updates

Use these references to check account eligibility, permitted expenses, contribution limits, and administrative requirements. Older IRS notices should be read with later changes, not as a source for current annual dollar limits. Publication 969 and Publication 503 were the 2025 editions at review; 2026 and published 2027 amounts come from the separate current authorities identified below.

  1. IRS Publication 969: Health Savings Accounts and Other Tax-Favored Health Plans. HSA eligibility, contributions, distributions, family rules, excess contributions, death, and FSA/HRA fundamentals.
  2. IRS Publication 15-B (2026): Employer’s Tax Guide to Fringe Benefits. Cafeteria-plan participation, payroll treatment, dependent care assistance, HSA contributions, and the 2026 QSEHRA ceiling.
  3. IRS REG-142695-05, in Internal Revenue Bulletin 2007-39. Proposed cafeteria-plan regulations addressing written plans, plan years, elections, substantiation, and HSA election changes. Identified as proposed guidance; subsequent statutory changes and notices govern later exceptions.
  4. IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32. Published 2026 health FSA salary-reduction and carryover limits and other annual adjustments.
  5. IRS inflation-adjusted tax items by tax year. Annual publication index. Check the official adjustment for the applicable tax year before using a new health FSA or QSEHRA limit. The amounts stated in this lesson identify the verified year.
  6. 26 CFR 54.9831-1. Health FSA excepted-benefit requirements and excepted benefit HRA conditions; use current revenue procedures for indexed dollar caps.
  7. Social Security Administration: Contribution and Benefit Base. Social Security wage ceilings and payroll tax context for the illustrative savings calculation.
  8. IRS Revenue Ruling 2003-43. FSA/HRA card substantiation and correction procedures. See also Chief Counsel Advice 202317020 for the IRS discussion of claims substantiation; that memorandum is not precedential guidance.
  9. IRS Notice 2002-45. HRA employer funding, benefit availability, nondiscrimination, and FSA/HRA payment ordering.
  10. IRS Publication 503: Child and Dependent Care Expenses. Qualifying persons, work-related care, earned income, and coordination with the tax credit; use Publication 15-B for the increased 2026 exclusion.
  11. IRS Notice 2013-54. Group-plan HRA integration and health FSA market-reform guidance; later QSEHRA and ICHRA authorities provide additional structures.
  12. IRS Notice 2015-87. HRA family integration and VA-care exceptions for HSA eligibility, among other subjects.
  13. IRS Notice 2017-67. QSEHRA employer eligibility, terms, coverage, reimbursement, and premium tax credit coordination.
  14. 26 CFR 54.9802-4. ICHRA integration, individual coverage, Medicare, employee classes, opt-outs, substantiation, and notices.
  15. HealthCare.gov: CHOICE Arrangements. Current public-facing terminology for ICHRAs, affordability, employee classes, and off-Marketplace pre-tax premium payments.
  16. IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-19. Published 2026 HSA, HDHP, and excepted benefit HRA amounts.
  17. IRS Revenue Procedure 2026-24. Published 2027 HSA, HDHP, DPC fee, and excepted benefit HRA amounts.
  18. IRS Notice 2026-5, in Internal Revenue Bulletin 2026-02. Telehealth, individual bronze and catastrophic coverage, and direct primary care changes under Public Law 119-21.
  19. IRS Revenue Ruling 2004-45. Limited-purpose, post-deductible, and other FSA/HRA structures affecting HSA eligibility. See also Notice 2008-59 for additional HSA guidance.
  20. IRS Notice 2004-50. Medicare enrollment, account ownership, deferred reimbursement, employer contributions, and cafeteria-plan interaction. Annual limits and subsequently changed rules in the original notice are historical.

Review the applicable plan-year and tax-year limits before publishing future editions. The 2027 health FSA limit ($3,500) and carryover ($700) were added after the IRS announcement in October 2026.

UP NEXT / MODULE 05

Ancillary & Supplemental Products

Continue with ancillary and supplemental products that round out the benefits package.

Continue to Module 5 →
← Back to Module 3
THE FULL COURSE

Six modules.
One connected foundation.

  1. 01

    Introduction to Employee Benefits

    History, networks, plan design, and funding.

    Open lesson
  2. 02

    Insurance Rules & Regulations

    Rulemaking, contributions, participation, benefits, and rating.

    Open lesson
  3. 03

    Large Employers

    Employer shared responsibility and reporting.

    Open lesson
  4. 04

    Tax-Advantaged Accounts

    Section 125 plans, FSAs, HRAs, and HSAs.

    This module
  5. 05

    Ancillary & Supplemental Products

    Build a benefits package beyond major medical.

    Open lesson
  6. 06

    Compliance Requirements and the Role of the Broker

    Plan responsibilities, communications, and employer value.

    Open lesson

Return to course overview →